Are e-books really Green?

Readers may have missed this engaging opinion piece in Sunday's New York Times: How Green Is My Ipad?

Granted, a true environmental audit of the life-cycle of either a printed book, or an Ipad, is presently an inexact science.  The authors present a plausible analysis, but it contains several asssumptions or unknowns, and given its length can't begin to get into the technicalities of print book production: illustrations? acid-free paper? binding type?  size of the volume? etc. –details which do matter in this context.

Still, very rough figuring in the world of libraries:

One e-book reader has the approximate impact of 100 printed book circulations (each circulation counting as one use, which is a debatable assumption).  Given the impact of individuals going to a library to get a book (on foot on campus, or using an automobile? or public transportation in a city? or a bicycle?), one might err generously and say that the approximate impact upon global climate change and human health would add up:

one e-book reader = 150 paper book circulations

but even that might be too generous.  Then must be figured in the cost of storage, retrieval, processing, and repair of printed books, which is a practically incalculable per-piece figure in an academic library with perhaps many hundred thousand volumes –some of which will remain in the collection for centuries or decades, while others are ephemeral.

A very general conclusion:  the positive environmental impact of e-book readers is often overerestimated, and the positive impact of many printed volumes is usually under-estimated.  In fact, paper is not a bad storage medium, in bulk.  It is expensive and time-consuming to handle.  On the other hand, the impacts on human health and global climate change of e-book readers and changing electronic formats cannot be over-looked in a pundits' rush to proclaim the death of the library.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s